Improving affordable housing delivery through the reduction of rework in the supply chain
Introduction
The UK housing market has faced significant challenges in recent decades, with a growing demand for housing outpacing the available supply1…. This imbalance has led to a shortage of affordable housing, particularly affecting younger generations and lower-income groups2. The issue has become a focal point for political debate, with various government initiatives and programs introduced to address the growing unaffordability of housing. However, several factors contribute to this complex problem, including a lack of investment, fluctuating market prices, financial instability, land availability, and regulatory hurdles. A critical aspect of the problem lies in the inefficiencies within the housing supply chain, particularly the prevalence of rework, which adds to production costs and delays. This document explores these issues, examining the causes of rework, the potential for lean thinking, and the role of technology in improving the delivery of affordable housing.
The Shortage of Affordable Housing
The UK’s housing shortage has been a long-standing issue, with projections indicating a significant shortfall of housing units. The number of houses built annually has struggled to keep pace with the increasing demand, with an average of 134,000 houses built per year over the last eight years. This falls short of the estimated 200,000 units needed annually. The situation is worsened by rising house prices, which have significantly outstripped average earnings. Government initiatives, such as the ‘Help to Buy’ scheme, have aimed to assist first-time buyers, but there is concern that these schemes may also contribute to price increases if not matched by an adequate supply response. The complex regulatory environment and planning restrictions also play a role, making it difficult to increase the housing supply.
The Impact of Rework on Housing Production Costs of Affordable Housing
One of the critical factors affecting the cost of housing production is the high level of rework within the supply chain. Rework refers to the need to redo tasks or correct mistakes, leading to increased costs and delays. The housing supply chain is often criticised for being wasteful, having low productivity, and poor quality. This is partly due to the fragmented nature of the sector, where numerous subcontractors are involved, leading to communication and coordination challenges. The cost of rework can be substantial, with estimates suggesting that it can add between 3% to 15% to the total project value10. Some studies have indicated rework costs can be as high as 23% of the contract value. These costs contribute to the overall expense of housing production, which then affects the affordability of homes.
Causes of Rework in Housing Production
Various factors contribute to rework in housing production, often stemming from poor managerial practices. These include:
- Managerial Issues: Lack of experience, imprecise design information, and inadequate construction procedures are key drivers of rework. Effective decision-making and strong communication are crucial to minimise errors.
- Poor Communication: Inadequate communication between the different stakeholders, including designers and subcontractors, can lead to unintended changes and rework. This lack of communication can result in increased resource needs, delays, and higher costs.
- Lack of Coordination and Collaboration: Poor coordination among subcontractors, often due to a lack of trust and transparency, also results in rework. When subcontractors focus on minimising their costs rather than collaborating effectively, defects often arise which can escalate costs.
- Client-Driven Changes: Client changes to requirements can lead to design errors which can have significant cost impacts.
- Unrealistic scheduling: Inefficient project scheduling is also a contributor to the rework problem.
- Lack of skilled labour: The absence of a suitably skilled workforce also generates problems.
- Poorly written instructions: Unclear instructions can lead to errors and rework.
- Untimely supply of materials can lead to delays and rework.
The Role of Lean Thinking
Lean thinking, which focuses on eliminating waste and improving workflow, has been successfully applied in manufacturing industries and offers a promising approach to address the challenges in the housing supply chain. The concept, originating from Toyota’s manufacturing system, emphasises optimisation of processes and minimisation of waste. Industrialised housing, which shares similarities with automobile production in terms of controllable production flow and high volumes, is well-suited to the application of lean principles. However, the construction industry has been slow to adopt lean practices due to the fragmented nature of the sector and lack of motivation for collaborative learning.
Technology and Innovation of Affordable Housing
Emerging technologies, such as Artificial Intelligence (AI), robotics, and manufactured housing, offer the potential to improve housing productivity and reduce errors. These technologies can streamline workflows, reduce the impact of human error, and enhance the efficiency of production processes23. Despite these opportunities, there is a resistance to adopting new technologies within the housing sector, often due to a lack of financial resources, particularly among SMEs. Additionally, many still prefer to use hard copies over Building Information Modelling (BIM) for project coordination, which demonstrates cultural resistance to change.
Conclusion
Addressing the UK’s housing affordability crisis requires a multifaceted approach, with a specific focus on improving the efficiency of the supply chain through the reduction of rework. The application of lean principles, supported by the adoption of new technologies, and improved managerial practices and communication can significantly improve housing production. By fostering collaboration among stakeholders and embracing innovative strategies, the UK can increase the quantity and quality of affordable housing.
For further reading:
Improving affordable housing delivery through the reduction of …
Supply chain management and operational efficiency in affordable …