Advisory Center for Affordable Settlements & Housing

Document Download Download
Document Type General
Publish Date 19/07/2017
Author Earnst & Young - Building a better world
Published By Earnst & Young
Edited By Suneela Farooqi
Uncategorized

Urban Resilience – The better the question. The better the answer. The better the world works.

Urban Resilience – The better the question. The better the answer. The better the world works.

Introduction

Urban resilience is a critical concept in today’s rapidly changing world, where cities face unprecedented challenges such as climate change, population growth, resource scarcity, and socio-economic inequalities. The document, titled “Urban Resilience – The better the question. The better the answer. The better the world works,” emphasizes that the ability of cities to adapt, recover, and thrive in the face of these challenges is not just a matter of infrastructure or technology but also of asking the right questions and fostering collaboration among stakeholders. By framing better questions, cities can develop more effective solutions that enhance urban resilience and create a better world for everyone.

Urban Resilience

The Importance of Urban Resilience

Cities are the engines of global economic growth, innovation, and culture. They are hubs of creativity, opportunity, and diversity, attracting people from all walks of life. However, they are also vulnerable to a wide range of shocks and stresses, from natural disasters like floods and earthquakes to systemic issues like unemployment, inequality, and social unrest. Urban resilience refers to the capacity of a city to withstand these disruptions, adapt to changing conditions, and transform in ways that improve the quality of life for its residents. The document argues that urban resilience is not just about bouncing back but also about bouncing forward—using crises as opportunities to build stronger, more equitable, and sustainable communities.

The concept of urban resilience is particularly relevant in the context of climate change, which is exacerbating risks such as extreme weather events, sea-level rise, and heatwaves. At the same time, cities are grappling with rapid urbanization, which is putting pressure on infrastructure, housing, and public services. These challenges are interconnected, and addressing them requires a holistic approach that considers the social, economic, and environmental dimensions of urban resilience.

Asking the Right Questions

The core message of the document is that the quality of the questions we ask determines the quality of the answers we find. Too often, cities focus on short-term fixes or siloed solutions that address symptoms rather than root causes. For example, a city might invest in flood defenses without considering how urban planning, land use, and climate change intersect to create vulnerability in the first place. By asking deeper, more systemic questions, cities can uncover the underlying drivers of risk and develop holistic strategies that enhance urban resilience across multiple dimensions.

The document provides examples of how reframing questions can lead to more innovative and effective solutions. For instance, instead of asking, “How can we reduce traffic congestion?” a city might ask, “How can we create a transportation system that improves access to jobs, reduces emissions, and enhances public health?” This broader question encourages policymakers to consider not just roads and vehicles but also public transit, cycling infrastructure, and urban design. It shifts the focus from isolated problems to interconnected systems, enabling more comprehensive and sustainable solutions that strengthen urban resilience.

Another example is the question of affordable housing. Instead of asking, “How can we build more housing?” a city might ask, “How can we create inclusive neighborhoods that provide affordable housing, access to services, and opportunities for social and economic mobility?” This approach recognizes that housing is not just a physical structure but a key determinant of well-being, equity, and urban resilience.

Collaboration and Co-Creation

Urban resilience cannot be achieved by any single actor or sector. It requires collaboration among governments, businesses, communities, and civil society organizations. The document highlights the importance of co-creation—bringing together diverse stakeholders to share knowledge, resources, and perspectives. This collaborative approach ensures that urban resilience strategies are inclusive, equitable, and grounded in the needs and aspirations of local communities.

One example of successful collaboration is the Resilient Cities Network, a global initiative that brings together cities to share best practices and develop innovative solutions to common challenges. By learning from each other’s experiences, cities can accelerate progress and avoid reinventing the wheel. The document also emphasizes the role of technology and data in enabling collaboration. For instance, digital platforms can facilitate real-time information sharing and decision-making during emergencies, while data analytics can help cities identify vulnerabilities and prioritize investments that enhance urban resilience.

Collaboration is particularly important in addressing complex challenges that cut across traditional boundaries, such as climate change and inequality. For example, a city might partner with local businesses to develop green infrastructure projects that reduce flood risk, create jobs, and enhance public spaces. Similarly, community organizations can play a vital role in building social resilience by fostering trust, solidarity, and collective action, all of which are essential for urban resilience.

Integrating Urban Resilience into Urban Planning

A key theme of the document is the need to integrate urban resilience into all aspects of urban planning and governance. This means moving beyond reactive approaches that focus on disaster response and recovery to proactive strategies that build urban resilience into the fabric of the city. For example, cities can incorporate climate resilience into zoning laws, building codes, and infrastructure projects to reduce vulnerability to extreme weather events. Similarly, social resilience can be strengthened by investing in affordable housing, education, and healthcare, which help communities withstand economic shocks and social disruptions.

The document also stresses the importance of long-term thinking and scenario planning. Cities need to anticipate future risks and opportunities, such as the impacts of climate change, technological advancements, and demographic shifts. By developing flexible and adaptive plans, cities can navigate uncertainty and seize opportunities for innovation and growth, all while enhancing urban resilience.

One example of integrated planning is the concept of “sponge cities,” which use natural systems to absorb and manage water. This approach not only reduces flood risk but also enhances biodiversity, improves air quality, and provides recreational spaces for residents—key components of urban resilience. Another example is the use of green roofs and walls, which can mitigate urban heat islands, reduce energy consumption, and improve mental health, further contributing to urban resilience.

Case Studies and Lessons Learned

The document includes several case studies that illustrate how cities around the world are building urban resilience through innovative approaches. These examples provide valuable lessons for other cities facing similar challenges.

  • Rotterdam, Netherlands: Facing the threat of sea-level rise, Rotterdam has transformed itself into a global leader in water management. The city has implemented a range of measures, from green roofs and water plazas to floating neighborhoods, that not only reduce flood risk but also enhance urban livability and sustainability. Rotterdam’s approach demonstrates the importance of integrating urban resilience into urban design and planning.
  • Medellín, Colombia: Once known for its high levels of violence and inequality, Medellín has undergone a remarkable transformation by investing in social infrastructure, such as libraries, parks, and public transit. These investments have not only improved quality of life but also fostered social cohesion and economic opportunity. Medellín’s experience highlights the role of social resilience in building stronger, more inclusive communities, a cornerstone of urban resilience.
  • Cape Town, South Africa: In response to a severe drought, Cape Town implemented a comprehensive water conservation program that included public awareness campaigns, tariff reforms, and investments in alternative water sources. The city’s efforts not only averted a water crisis but also strengthened its capacity to manage future shocks. Cape Town’s case underscores the importance of proactive governance and community engagement in building urban resilience.

These case studies demonstrate that urban resilience is not a one-size-fits-all concept. Each city must tailor its approach to its unique context, challenges, and opportunities. However, they also highlight common principles, such as the importance of leadership, innovation, and community engagement, all of which are essential for urban resilience.

The Role of Leadership and Governance

Leadership plays a crucial role in driving urban resilience. The document argues that resilient cities are characterized by visionary leaders who can inspire collective action, mobilize resources, and navigate complex trade-offs. Effective leadership also requires transparency, accountability, and a commitment to equity and inclusion. For example, cities that involve marginalized communities in decision-making are better able to address the root causes of vulnerability and build trust and social capital, both of which are critical for urban resilience.

Governance structures also matter. The document calls for more integrated and adaptive governance systems that can respond to the interconnected nature of urban challenges. This includes breaking down silos between different levels of government and sectors, as well as fostering partnerships with the private sector and civil society. For example, a city might establish a resilience office that coordinates efforts across departments and engages stakeholders in co-creating solutions that enhance urban resilience.

The Economic Case for Urban Resilience

Investing in urban resilience is not just a moral imperative but also an economic one. The document highlights the growing body of evidence that shows how resilience investments can deliver significant economic returns. For example, every dollar spent on disaster risk reduction can save up to seven dollars in recovery costs. Similarly, investments in green infrastructure, such as parks and wetlands, can generate multiple benefits, including flood protection, carbon sequestration, and recreational opportunities—all of which contribute to urban resilience.

Moreover, resilient cities are more attractive to businesses, investors, and talent. Companies are increasingly looking for locations that offer stability, sustainability, and quality of life, while workers are drawn to cities that provide opportunities for education, healthcare, and cultural enrichment. By building urban resilience, cities can enhance their competitiveness and create a virtuous cycle of growth and innovation.

A Call to Action

The document concludes with a call to action for cities, businesses, and individuals to prioritize urban resilience in their planning, investments, and daily lives. It emphasizes that urban resilience is not a destination but a journey—one that requires continuous learning, adaptation, and collaboration. By asking better questions, cities can find better answers and create a better world for future generations.

In summary, “Urban Resilience – The better the question. The better the answer. The better the world works.” is a thought-provoking exploration of how cities can build urban resilience in the face of complex and interconnected challenges. It underscores the importance of systemic thinking, collaboration, and leadership in creating cities that are not only resilient but also equitable, sustainable, and thriving. By reframing the way we approach urban challenges, we can unlock new possibilities and build a better future for all.

Also read: Housing Policy Options to Tackle Urban Inequalities

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *